Saturday, October 17, 2009

Ethical Dilemmas

Today let's discuss ethical dilemmas. A Louisiana justice refused an interracial couple a marriage license. You can read the article here:

http://news.aol.com/article/interracial-couple-denied-marriage/719806?icid=main|htmlws-sb|dl1|link4|http%3A%2F%2Fnews.aol.com%2Farticle%2Finterracial-couple-denied-
marriage%2F719806


Personally I think the justice is a racist pig but he was being true to himself and his beliefs. I just think this is a case where you suppress your beliefs and do what the law allows. What do you think?

Just for fun what would you do in the following situations: (My answers follow each question)

You are on a country road and see two neighboring farm houses on fire. One is yours and the other belongs to a new couple who just moved in. Your wife and child are at home as are your neighbors. You can only save one house. Which one do you save? (Of course I save my house and call 911 for the other house)

You run an orphanage and have had a hard time making ends meet. A car dealership offers you a new van worth $15,000 for free if you will falsely report to the government that the dealership donated a van worth $30,000. You really need the van and it will give you an opportunity to make the children happy. Do you agree to take the van? (Nope)

You are shopping and notice a woman stuffing a pair of stockings into her purse. Do you report her? (I should report her but in all reality I wouldn't because I wouldn't want to get involved.)

You discover a wallet lying on the street. It contains $1000.00 and has his id in it. Do you send it back to him? (Yes. I've actually done this before.)

It is 3 a.m. and you are late getting home. As you approach the intersection you notice that no one is around. Do you drive through the red light? (I know the correct answer but I'm going through the damn light)

You can only rescue one of each of the following, which do you save?

a) A child or an adult (I'd cheat and rescue them both)

b) A stranger or your dog (the stranger unless it was Limbaugh or O'Reily)

c) Hitler or lassie. (Lassie)

d) Your spouse or a Nobel Laureate (Spouse. No hesitation.)

It is going to be interesting to see if your ethics are as flexible as mine! May your day be filled more with joy then ethical dilemmas!

TODAY'S TRIVIA;

Yesterday's answer: Amelia Jenks Bloomer

Today's is from Connie. If any of you have a hero or someone that you think would make a good Who Am I please go ahead and send them to me.

I was born in either 1919 or 1922. After my mother died when I was 14 I was looked after by other staff members at the hospital where she had worked. I went on to become a cardiologist. After World War II I authored books documenting the history of wartime resistance against the Nazi German occupation. In 1939, after the German invasion of Poland I was confined to the Warsaw Ghetto. In 1942 I founded an underground group. With the help of my comrades we began obtaining weapons and organizing into units that would make up for lack of training and munitions with an intimate knowledge of the Ghetto. In 1943 we started an uprising. On the second day of the Uprising a prominent insurgent was killed. Over the next three week the fighting was intense. We killed dozens of Nazi soldiers. On May 8 my commander was surrounded by Nazi soldiers and killed himself leaving me in charge. The Germans proceeded to flush out the remaining fighters by burning down the Ghetto. We escaped through the sewers and made our way to the non-Ghetto part of Warsaw. After World War II the Uprising was sometimes given as an unusual instance of active Jewish resistance in the face of the horror perpetrated by the Germans. We knew perfectly well that we had no chance of winning. We fought simply not to allow the Germans alone to pick the time and place of our deaths. When asked of my heroics I was quoted as saying: "We knew we were going to die. Just like all the others who were sent to Treblinka.... Their death was far more heroic. We didn't know when we would take a bullet. They had to deal with certain death, stripped naked in a gas chamber or standing at the edge of a mass grave waiting for a bullet in the back of the head.... It was easier to die fighting than in a gas chamber." In mid-1944 I participated in another Uprising when Polish forces rose up against the Germans before being forced to surrender after 63 days of fighting. In 1981 despite it being dangerous to speak out in the country that I lived in I denounced racism and promoted human rights and later was interned by the government. In 1983 I refused to take part in the official celebrations of the 40th anniversary of the aforementioned Uprising sponsored by the Communist government. I believed that this would be an act of cynicism and contempt in a country where social life was dominated throughout by humiliation and coercion. Instead I walked with friends to the street where a comrade's bunker had been located. In my old age I spoke up for the Palestinians as I felt that the Jewish self-defense for which he had fought was in danger of crossing the line into oppression. In August 2002 I wrote an open letter to the Palestinian resistance leaders. Though the letter criticized the suicide bombers, its tone infuriated the Israeli government and press. I wrote in a spirit of solidarity from a fellow resistance fighter, as a former leader of a Jewish uprising not dissimilar in desperation to the Palestinian uprising in the occupied territories. There was a howl of rage in the Israeli press, especially since I had consciously used the terms that described the structures of the resistance movement in WWII. I was awarded the Order of the White Eagle and the French Legion of Honour. I was married and had two children. When my wife and children emigrated from the communist country we lived in to France I stayed behind and each April I laid flowers in my country for those who had served with me in the uprising. I died October 2, 2009. Who Am I?

6 comments:

Pat said...

I agree with you that the judge is a racist pig. You always know when they start out, "I'm not a racist, but..." A judge in his professional capacity should follow the law. Though I do think there's some question, not in that case, but in some areas there seems occasionally a disconnect between law and justice. But that's another soapbox.

I'd save my own house. Only I probably couldn't save either one, and would call 911 first.

I'd sure be tempted with the van thing, but I'd be afraid of the IRS and would probably decline.

I probably wouldn't report the woman stealing stockings. Even though I should. I'd hope the store people saw it, too.

I would return the wallet. Much as I'd like an extra $1K, it wouldn't be worth my conscience nagging me.

I don't drive through red lights ever. The local police can be very sneaky and you never know when one is lurking in wait just for you.

Who would I rescue? I don't get many chances to rescue anyone, but I'd probably go for the child.

The stranger. Probably. Which dog?

Lassie, of course.

Spouse, probably. Which spouse? If the first one, there might be a moment's indecision. Besides, how would I know who was a Nobel Laureate? Maybe it would depend on what s/he was a laureate FOR. {eg}

William J. said...

Hi Pat

OK, we will change the question, your spouse or Antonio Banderas?

I know what soapbox you are referring too and I agree with you, sometimes the law isn't moral, it is exclusive.

With me, if I did that with the Van, I'd lose my license. That is why for me there is no way I'd agree to it.

Bill

Pat said...

My spouse or Antonio? Ha! I repeat the question, Which spouse? [g]

I see you sometimes share my soapbox. Actually it's not a soapbox, as I don't usually talk about it, but my private thoughts incline more to justice, assuming I can tell what that is.

William J. said...

Hi Pat

Geez I thought you would go for Banderas without hesitation!

I don't talk about the soapbox either because people are so embedded with their opinion that you won't change any minds.

Bill

Lady DR said...

Ethics -- you do make us think, Mr. D.

Yes, I think the JP is racist and I don't think his position allows him to make moral judgements that go against laws and statutes. I don't know the stats on interracial marriages. I do know divorce stats are abysmal, but haven't seen them attributed to race. As to the particular justice, does he have the right or (whatever) to take a position such as this, in which his personal beliefs run counter to the laws of the state?

Fires: I think I'd call 911 from my cell, then head to my house to rescue my family.

Orphanage/Van: I'd turn in the dealer's offer, hope it made headlines and I'd end up with a couple free vans from dealers who wanted to be heroes.

The lady with the stockings: Not at all sure what I'd do. Probably rely on store cameras and security, as I'm not sure I could be positive she was stealing them -- I have seen people put items in totebags, while shopping, then take them to the counter and pay for them.

I tend to always wait on red lights as, in my area, you're never sure if some car will come out of nowhere, regardless of the color of the lght.

The wallet definitely goes back to the owner. I have to look in the mirror every morning to comb my hair and I'm a terrible liar. A grand isn't enough to buy me peace of mind, regardless of the bills it might pay. Then again, if I was out of work and my kids hadn't eaten in two days... who knows?

The "who do you save" questions are tough. Like you and others, I'df try to save both the adult and child. I guess my gut instinct would be child first, hoping the adult could manage until I got back for him/her. I'd go for the human stranger, trusting my dog to follow my commands, if able. Lassie wins, hands down. Spouse is first priority -- he's worth a dozen laureautes, at least, since he's mine, he's here, he loves me, forgives me, understands me and supports me. Can't think of a single Laureaute of whom I can say the same. As a person who cares about the human race and others, he can certainly hold his own. Now, if my choice is Banderas... uh, who's that? Do I need to get out more?

William J. said...

Hi DR

Banderas is an actor that most women I know go gaga over. If you haven't seen the movie Take The Lead rent it, he is the dance instructor in it. Good movie.

I once dated a woman that had black children (she was white, former husband black) and we were definitely treated differently. A lot worse actually. Marriages are tuff and I would imagine even tougher among interracial couples. But it isn't my position in life to keep people that love each other no matter what race or orientation they are that they can't get married.

Very inventive van answer.

Even if my kids hadn't eaten for two days I'd turn in the wallet and hope for a reward that would give my kids a meal.

How lucky Himself is to have a spouse that loves him like you do!

Bill